Influencers Suck
This post is a cautionary tale for marketers thinking about running influencer campaigns. It’s harder than it looks.
Virgin America and Klout did an influencer campaign in Toronto to promote Virgin’s new Toronto to San Francisco route. Klout is a tool that measures how “influential” a person is on Twitter. Influential Twitter users were offered a free flight to California and invited to a party to be attended by Sir Richard Branson himself. I was selected as one of those lucky folks. At first I thought the campaign was a stroke of marketing genius. Do something really remarkable for a bunch of noisy people and you can pretty much guarantee that we will tell everybody we know about it. Oh, if only life were so simple. That’s the dirty secret of marketing – ideas are easy, it’s the execution that’s tricky.
As you might expect, folks not offered free flights complained about the selection criteria, the tool, and that Klout was “buying Tweets”. More invitations were issued and word spread that complaining about not getting invited might actually get you invited, spawning an additional wave of complaining. Influencers who did not register for the party within a 1.5 hour window were un-invited. More complaining. At the pre-party meetup, Klout employees didn’t seem to know any of the chosen influencers and a distracted Klout employee walked away from guests mid-conversation. Complaining. The launch party invite email had errors. Complaining. Influencers were not VIP enough to enter the VIP area at the party. Complaining. Each misstep was very minor but taken together, a campaign that had started out with great buzz devolved into a Twittter complain-a-palooza. I last saw the Klout folks huddled together at the launch party and none of them made a move to talk to the group of influencers a few steps away. Given we were likely to complain about that as well, I couldn’t blame them.
It Sucks Dealing with Cranky-Pants Influencers (but you still have to do it)
In fact, I felt badly for them. They DID do a lot of things right. They were open about how they selected people and published a blog post on it. They directly communicated that accepting the gift did not mean you were obliged to talk about it and they advised people to disclose that they had received the gift if they wrote about it. Their tool in my opinion, is by far the best way of measuring true reach and interaction on Twitter and they are pretty explicit on their site about what they are measuring and why. It might not be perfect but this is a startup we’re talking about here, not IBM research labs and in this case I don’t think perfection is possible. The tool is blazing a trail in uncharted territory which, for those of you that have never done that, is really, really hard. The tool is also improving at a remarkably rapid rate from what I’ve seen.
But as my father would say “you can’t sell if you can’t deal with the public” and this particular brand of public is famous for being critical of companies that do not appear to understand or value their community. Trying to influence any group of people is hard work. If that group happens to be heavy social media users, I would argue it’s harder still. But it isn’t impossible. Here are a few examples (featuring folks that would make my Toronto “influential” list):
1/ Working with a Community
I witnessed Erin Bury, community manager for Sprouter, work her magic at the blogger lounge at SxSW this year. Within an hour she had met everyone in the room and when I say “met”, I don’t mean forking over a business card. She asked smart questions, listened, and probed for ways she or her company could help people. She Tweeted thank-you’s to folks for taking the time to talk and later Sprouter featured some of those people in their newsletter and blog. Erin doesn’t have free flights to give away but she wins people over by giving her time, her help and her respect.
2/ Running an Influencer Event
I attended a Rogers blogger event organized by Dave Fleet and the folks at Thornley Fallis (disclosure: I don’t work for TF but I have freeloaded office space from them). I was greeted when I arrived and people I hadn’t met yet knew who I was. Everyone working the event spoke to me and asked questions. The event was well-staffed and we all got a chance to spend as much time as we wanted with Rogers people. We were given a Twitter hashtag and Tweeted like mad. Loads of time was set aside to let us ask questions and the Rogers folks seemed open to feedback. On the way out everyone thanked me for coming. Nobody complained and they made it look easy. You try running a blogger event for a phone company and not have anyone complain. It’s not easy.
3/ Dealing with Criticism
If you’re on Twitter you likely follow @unmarketing. Scott Stratten is a speaker and consultant with a book on the way. He’s a one-man Twitter university for folks trying to figure it out and he teaches with wit and humility. He’s famous and like all famous people, he’s got detractors. People have gone so far as to create anonymous Twitter accounts for the sole purpose of picking on him. So what does Scott do? He tries to understand and where there is nothing he can do, he sucks it up. He’s nice to everyone and engages with everyone, even people who don’t return the favor, but if folks cross the line or are immovably anti-@unmarketing, he’ll directly and openly tell them to scram and ignore them. He maintains the difficult balance between being open to feedback and “feeding the trolls.” He does remarkably little complaining about @unmarketing haters while he continues to do his (clearly working) thing.
So for you marketers thinking about running influencer campaigns, consider yourselves warned. It’s harder than it looks. As for Klout I’m sure they will iron out the kinks and learn from the experience like all good startups. I’m a big fan of the tool and I’d like them to be successful. And maybe the next time they visit Toronto we will be less cranky. Maybe. Yeah, probably not. Influencers suck.
Oh and if any of you readers are in San Francisco July 25th to 28th, let me know, I’d love to have coffee 
Hey, you made it all the way to the end! You should subscribe! You can sign up for email updates, subscribe via RSS or follow me on Twitter.
Category: Social Media, Startups
Subscribe
If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to receive more just like it.
RT @aprildunford: Blog post – Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM (if u missed it) #prodmgmt #marketing
RT @aprildunford: Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM
RT @aprildunford: Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM Great post! Salutary lessons
[Toudoto] Les influenceurs du web sont des emmerdeurs : retour sur l'opération Virgin America / @Klout. http://ping.fm/wpDQW (via @loic)
Les influenceurs du web sont des emmerdeurs : retour sur l'opération Virgin America / @Klout. http://ping.fm/wpDQW (RT @eni_kao) #emarketing
Per usual, @aprildunford provides insight, balance, & wise counsel: Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM
Per usual, @aprildunford provides insight, balance, & wise counsel: Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM
Per usual, @aprildunford provides insight, balance, & wise counsel: Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM
RT @aprildunford: Blog post – Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM (if u missed it) #prodmgmt #marketing : So true.
RT @Jennifer_JJ: Per usual, @aprildunford provides insight, balance, & wise counsel: Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM
Influencers Suck : http://tinyurl.com/235vx5u – Thanks @aprildunford for the insight. Once again, words of wisdom.
[...] already written a post with my opinions as to why this particular campaign was met with a lot of whining criticism on and off Twitter, and the areas where I think the campaign struggled. Once I sat down [...]
This post is a cautionary tale for marketers thinking about running influencer campaigns.? It's harder than it look http://sorturl.net/?cfe
[...] The problem is most of the bloggers were pissed off and none of this was the fault of Virgin. April Dunford of Rocket Watcher beat me to summing this up so instead I wanted to look at why this happened (and how you can prevent [...]
Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM (via @aprildunford @unmarketing @brett) #fb
Why is it that, given the option, most people would rather tear someone down than help build them up?
It sounds like the people behind the event had the best intentions, but just didn’t execute as well as they would have liked. Sure, it’s an unfortunate turn of events that may have bent a few noses out of shape; but it’s too bad it had to turn into a public stoning.
If I were going to launch this kind of event, I’d try to get the Influencers to collaborate with me on both the planning and execution … bring them into the process so that they share responsibility. I’m all about collaboration & this seems like the perfect opportunity to work together towards a common goal. Maybe next time.
Hi Jamie,
I think you are getting at exactly the problem. If the campaign had been more about the influencers and less about about Klout, I think it would have been a really different outcome.
Thanks for the comment!
April
RT @aprildunford: Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM {Prickly and fickle – such fun!}
Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" via @aprildunford http://bit.ly/apmblM
RT @MarketingProfs: Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" via @aprildunford http://bit.ly/apmblM
RT @MarketingProfs: Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" http://bit.ly/apmblM #klout
RT @MarketingProfs: Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" http://bit.ly/apmblM #klout
April,
I get the gist of what you’re saying and the counsel you offer is spot-on.
I don’t think the concept behind Virgin and Klout’s idea was flawed. There’s nothing wrong with working with influencers. It’s a sound strategy. But as a third-party looking in, my first instinct is telling me that it looks like the companies involved just tried to buy a whole lot of love without trying to nurture it first.
Bottom line — Just like in real-world relationships, you can’t just buy love and expect bliss to ensue. You have to earn it first. If I popped a ring on the first date, the woman who eventually became my wife would’ve slapped me upside the head.
– Michael E. Rubin | http://flavors.me/merubin75
Disclosure: I work for Fifth Third Bank, and this is my own opinion.
Hi Michael,
Thanks for your comment. That’s exactly it.
I focused on Klout in the article and not Virgin but I should mention that I thought Virgin did an amazing job on the event. Richard Branson spent hours working the room and he took his time and spoke personally to everyone that wanted to speak with him. He was a total star at the event. Had Klout folks worked with the influencers like that, everything would have been fine I think.
April
Reading this takes the sting out of being deemed not influential enough to participate. I’m in SF and would love to meet up for coffee during your visit. Lemme know.
You could always complain a bit on Twitter – I heard that worked in Toronto
I’d love to catch a coffee with you! I will drop you a note.
Thanks for the comment!
April
RT @MarketingProfs: Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" via @aprildunford http://bit.ly/apmblM
RT @MarketingProfs: Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" via @aprildunford http://bit.ly/apmblM
RT @MarketingProfs: Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" via @aprildunford http://bit.ly/apmblM
RT @MarketingProfs: Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" via @aprildunford http://bit.ly/apmblM
Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" http://ow.ly/29clF #twitter #klout
RT @marketingprofs Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" via @aprildunford http://bit.ly/apmblM
Influencers suck. http://bit.ly/cN0mQm Witty recap of Virgin Atlantic/Klout giveaway by @aprildunford
RT @MarketingProfs: Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" via @aprildunford http://bit.ly/apmblM
RT @MarketingProfs: Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" via @aprildunford http://bit.ly/apmblM
Influencers suck. Dirty secret of marketing – ideas are easy, it’s the execution that’s tricky. thx @katgordon http://bit.ly/cN0mQm
RT @BrandNarrative: Dirty secret of marketing – ideas are easy, it’s the execution that’s tricky. thx @katgordon http://bit.ly/cN0mQm
RT @MarketingProfs: Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" via @aprildunford http://bit.ly/apmblM
influencer campaigns depend on the execution – dos and don'ts RT @dukkytweets RT @MarketingProfs: "Influencers Suck" http://bit.ly/apmblM
It sucks dealing with cranky-pants influencers (but you have to do it) http://bit.ly/b3ppvJ via @aprildunford @MeganLeap @marketingprofs
Good read! > Influencer Marketing is Hard | Rocket Watcher Product Marketing for Startups http://bit.ly/bCQ43W
Weren't u invited 2 this @garybembridge ? RT @heykarri It sucks dealing with cranky-pants influencers http://bit.ly/b3ppvJ
Good insight for brands trying to figure out social: "Influencers Suck" via @aprildunford http://bit.ly/apmblM #brand #socialmedia
Interesting article on running an influencer campaign: http://bit.ly/d4LTBc
Thanks @jgombita for this – loved it
Influencer Marketing is Hard http://bit.ly/bqz5wX via @addthis worth the read tweeps!
Hi April,
good article on influencers. even though it didn’t go as planned, at least they’re trying. In my eyes given all the clients that I work with is more than what most traditional businesses are doing.
Thanks for the links to the other SM experts!
Marc
Getting caught up on RT @aprildunford: Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM Useful AND funny!
RT @aprildunford: Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM
Influencer marketing can be hard, as @virginamerica and @klout realized http://ow.ly/2A5Lv (via @aprildunford)
RT @simpliflying: Influencer marketing can be hard, as @virginamerica and @klout realized http://ow.ly/2A5Lv (via @aprildunford)
Influencers Suck. Good read by @aprildunford – http://bit.ly/d4LTBc
RT @aprildunford: Influencers Suck http://bit.ly/apmblM
The problem of dealing with "influences" [example] – http://ht.ly/32zDn